Alev Scott is a journalist and author. Her new book, co-written with Andronike Makris, is Power & the People: Five Lessons from the Birthplace of Democracy (Riverrun, 2019)
In 427 BC, the Athenian demagogue Cleon declared that “democracy is incapable of empire” – a surprisingly modern view recorded for us by the historian Thucydides in his account of the Peloponnesian War fought between democratic Athens and oligarchic Sparta in the years 431–405 BC.
Nearly 2,500 years ago, the tension between superpower status and democratic ideals had already become obvious to political leaders and voters alike. The Athenians, early pioneers of democracy and masters of naval supremacy, understood that maintaining an empire requires some heavy handling of both subject states and allies. Cleon was advocating a less democratic, more decisive foreign…
