Although the New York Times eulogized Belle Case La Follette in 1931 as perhaps “the most influential of all American women who have had to do with public affairs in this country,” she faded quickly from popular memory.1 And when she is recalled, it’s usually in relation to her husband and sons. This minimization of her own accomplishments began with progressive reform giant Robert M. La Follette famously calling her “my wisest and best counselor.” He openly deferred to his wife’s judgment throughout his storied professional life: as a district attorney, three-term congressman (1885–1891), lawyer (1891–1900), three-term governor of Wisconsin (1900–1906), and, most significantly, during his nineteen years in the US Senate (1906–1925).
According to their son-in-law, playwright George Middleton, “Except John Adams with his Abigail, no man in public life was…