Elie Hirschfeld grew up in New York, develops real estate in New York, and has long bought art depicting New York—by Rothko, Rockwell, O’Keeffe, Hockney, Lawrence, Hopper, and others—for a collection once kept largely at his Manhattan apartment, across from the Met. He and his wife, Sarah, are donating the collection to the New-York Historical Society. (An exhibition of the works opens on October 22nd.) Before it moved, they gave a visitor a tour. Paintings hung on walls and reclined on couches, like guests. Hirschfeld, seventy-one, is tall, lean, and balding; Sarah, sixty-one, a doctor and a scientist, is shorter, with dark hair. They both possess a serene but exacting demeanor.
The collection has strong architectural themes. Hirschfeld gestured at a painting of snowy, small-town Brooklyn in 1818, by Francis…