On a Saturday evening last month, two judges walked into a bar—O.K., a restaurant: Bella Blu, on the Upper East Side, where the pre-theatre crowd was fuelling up for “The Lehman Trilogy,” at the Park Avenue Armory. The play tells the story of Lehman Brothers, from the firm’s founding, in 1850, by a trio of Bavarian-Jewish immigrants in Montgomery, Alabama, to its collapse, at 1:45 a.m. on September 15, 2008, when it filed for bankruptcy in the Southern District of New York, triggering the global financial meltdown. Enter the judges, James Peck and Shelley Chapman. The case was assigned to Peck’s docket. Several years later, he retired, and Chapman took over. Between them, they have presided over many thousands of Lehman-related hearings, involving more than a trillion dollars in claims.…
