Since The Holdovers hit theaters, the word “cozy” has been at the center of a (good-natured) debate. Viewers and critics looked to the word as a descriptor for its setting (a prep school’s campus during Christmastime), its star (Paul Giamatti, spectacled, mustachioed and sporting corduroys and knits), its period (a nostalgiaclad 1970). Director Alexander Payne, quite vocally, doesn’t agree — there’s a lighthearted, almost saccharine connotation to the term that, understandably, grates on him. The Holdovers, despite its more festive elements, is a cerebral movie about three lost souls (an isolated professor, a recently bereaved mother, a hapless and left-behind student) enduring the loneliest winter break of their lives.
But it wouldn’t be awards season without a few semantics. Giamatti, for his part, takes no umbrage with coziness. “I know…