As fodder for true-crime dramas, the Candy Montgomery case is hard to top: On June 13, 1980, nearly two years after Candy (played here by Elizabeth Olsen) and Allan Gore (Jesse Plemons) began their extramarital affair, she stopped in for a visit with his wife, Betty (Lily Rabe), and somehow wound up hitting her 41 times with an axe.
The premise is so irresistible, in fact, that it was chronicled just last year in Hulu’s Candy — which, though certainly not Love & Death’s fault, does it few favors. Creator David E. Kelley does differentiate his miniseries with a more restrained and empathetic tone, in contrast to Candy’s sour sensationalism. But despite generous pacing and fine performances, his seven-part HBO Max show has too little light to shed on its…