IT’S AN UNDISPUTED TRUTH that pimiento cheese is a quintessential staple in the South, and you’d be hard-pressed to find a church picnic, covered-dish supper, or family gathering that doesn’t feature this beloved spread. And while Southern cooks made it the homestyle favorite we know and love today, it got its start up north.
In the 1870s, farmers in New York started making a soft, unripened cheese that eventually evolved into cream cheese. Also, Spain, around that time, started canning red peppers, or pimientos, and shipping their goods to the United States. Both new items were quickly embraced and became essential in households across the country. A Good Housekeeping magazine recipe from 1908 is the first known use of the ingredients together with a dish featuring cream cheese, mustard, chives,…