AMERICANS GO NUTS for peanut butter—not just spread on PB&Js but also baked into cookies, pies, and cakes; swirled into brownies and frostings; and even stirred into soups and sauces.
There are a ton of options: creamy and crunchy styles, of course, but also flavored, organic, “no-stir,” and “natural” peanut butters. The last category has expanded significantly, with major brands, including Skippy and Jif, offering natural options, too.
For this tasting, we focused on creamy peanut butter; it’s more popular than crunchy peanut butter, and it’s the type we use most often in recipes. We tried nine top-selling creamy peanut butters—three traditional and six natural, priced from $2.69 to $6.01 per jar—plain, in peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, and in peanut butter cookies.
At its most basic, peanut butter is…
