Controversial in life, Mary, Queen of Scots has divided posterity. Variously cast as a “popish whore”, husband-killer and traitress, or else as an innocent victim and glorious martyr to the Catholic faith, Mary continues to fascinate scholars, imaginative writers and the general public.
In scholarship and popular biography alike, one assumption long reigned supreme: that, in all she did, Mary was guided by passion – in sharp contrast with her English cousin and nemesis, Elizabeth I, epitome of political wisdom and just rule.
Since the 1990s, the myth of ‘Good Queen Bess' has been comprehensively dismantled, and the oft-astringent criticism, even defamation, of Elizabeth by her subjects – and not just Catholic ones – brought to light. Meanwhile, the Scottish queen has been recognised as a far more savvy, artful…
