In his new book, Seamus O'Maho ny invites readers to view the shifting fortunes of three men over the course of nearly four decades. The guru in question is Sigmund Freud; the bagman is his most devoted disciple, Ernest Jones; the sceptic is Jones's brother-in-law, eminent surgeon Wilfred Trotter. There's a particular focus on psychoanalysis – which the author, like Trotter, clearly regards as a cult, not a science. “Psychoanalysis,” he remarks, “became a home for rich directionless strays, who analysed other rich directionless strays.”
If O'Mahony is essentially dismissive of Freud's intellectual legacy, he displays a grudging respect for the man himself. Trotter, the sceptical Englishman, with his dexterity as a surgeon and his innate modesty, is most sympathetically portrayed. Least favoured is the industrious but sycophantic Jones, whose…
