There were a lot of questions flying around this past summer when AJ Shreffler, the chef and owner of Little Arthur’s in Capitol Hill, announced on Instagram that his pizza would be “the most expensive in town.” Reddit posters asked, “How and in what universe is someone getting away with charging $40/pizza?” and “Has anyone looked into the cost of dough, sauce, and cheese? What a joke” and simply “WTF?”
I had a question, too: Well, is it worth it?
A Pennsylvania native, Shreffler started with hoagies in 2019. In his home kitchen, he made the kind of sandwiches he missed eating back East and sold them via pop-ups. Those sandwiches, too, were criticized for their prices, which currently range from $22 for an Italian to $24 for a cheesesteak.…
